In The Web That Has No Weaver, Ted Kaptchuk describes some strange ideas that many Westerners have of Chinese medicine. He says that some see it as “hocus pocus” and the product of “primitive” thinking. Any seeming cure that occurs must come about by coincidence or by placebo effect. Other’s have set Chinese medicine on a pedestal and attribute spiritual qualities to it. He claims that both attitudes are “barriers to understanding” what Chinese medicine is all about. He describes it as an independent, coherent system of thought and practice that has been developed over two millennia.
Dr. Huisheng Xie, one of the leaders in TCVM in the United States, writes, “The goals of WVM and TCVM are the same. Both hope to promote health and prevent disease. They are merely 2 different ways of viewing the world and each has its own strengths and weaknesses… Thus, through integration of the 2 systems, one may take advantage of the strengths of each while minimizing the weaknesses.” The two disciplines do overlap; they are not mutually exclusive. The primary difference is that WVM emphasizes control and is more mechanistic while TCVM emphasizes balance and is more energetic. The Chinese system is not less logical than Western medicine, just less analytical.
TCVM looks for patterns of disharmony which describe areas of imbalance within the body. The goal is to recognize the pattern, bring back balance and restore harmony. This involves understanding and exploring relationships within the body’s physiologic systems as well as the psychological influences of disease. WVM is also starting to explore the role of stress, or psychological illness, as a factor in causing disease in our pets.